| David Watson | D | 2023-10-02 | Darnall & Handsworth B v Rotherham A | Div 2 - Weston Trophy |
| Ken A McIntosh | L | 2023-10-11 | Rotherham A v Ecclesall B | Div 2 - Weston Trophy |
| Neil Todd | D | 2023-10-17 | Barnsley v Rotherham | Richardson Cup |
| Khaled Muflehi | L | 2023-11-01 | Rotherham A v Hillsborough B | Div 2 - Weston Trophy |
| Phil Griffiths | D | 2023-11-15 | Rotherham v Worksop | Richardson Cup |
| Ionel Dragan | L | 2023-11-22 | Rotherham A v Worksop B | Div 2 - Weston Trophy |
| Callum Brewerton | L | 2023-11-29 | Rotherham A v Sheffield University A | Div 2 - Weston Trophy |
| Andrew Butterworth | W | 2023-12-12 | Barnsley A v Rotherham A | Div 2 - Weston Trophy |
| Daniel JS Sullivan | L | 2023-12-19 | Sheffield Nomads B v Rotherham A | Div 2 - Weston Trophy |
| Peter Micklethwaite | L | 2024-01-24 | Rotherham A v Barnsley A | Div 2 - Weston Trophy |
| Edouardos Ter Gevorkian | L | 2024-01-31 | Rotherham A v Darnall & Handsworth B | Div 2 - Weston Trophy |
| Alan S McIntosh | L | 2024-02-07 | Ecclesall B v Rotherham A | Div 2 - Weston Trophy |
| John R Mercy | L | 2024-02-19 | Hillsborough B v Rotherham A | Div 2 - Weston Trophy |
| Phill J Beckett | D | 2024-02-26 | Worksop B v Rotherham A | Div 2 - Weston Trophy |
| Henry Withington | D | 2024-04-10 | Rotherham A v Sheffield Nomads B | Div 2 - Weston Trophy |
| Ivan Dunnachie | W | 2024-04-17 | Sheffield University A v Rotherham A | Div 2 - Weston Trophy |
