| John M Oughton | D | 2023-09-25 | Darnall & Handsworth D v Hillsborough C | Div 4 - Athenaeum Cup |
| Michael W Simmons | W | 2023-10-04 | Sheffield Deaf A v Hillsborough C | Div 4 - Athenaeum Cup |
| Steven Harrison | L | 2023-10-09 | Ravenfield A v Hillsborough C | Div 4 - Athenaeum Cup |
| Tom Key | L | 2023-10-23 | Hillsborough C v SASCA C | Div 4 - Athenaeum Cup |
| Connor Fairfield | W | 2023-10-30 | Hillsborough C v Woodseats D | Div 4 - Athenaeum Cup |
| Richard Dawson | L | 2023-11-06 | Hillsborough C v Chesterfield C | Div 4 - Athenaeum Cup |
| Tom R W Edwards | W | 2023-11-27 | Hillsborough C v Barnsley C | Div 4 - Athenaeum Cup |
| Matt Wardman | L | 2023-12-11 | Woodseats C v Hillsborough C | Div 4 - Athenaeum Cup |
| Ben J Fletcher | D | 2024-01-22 | Hillsborough C v Sheffield Deaf A | Div 4 - Athenaeum Cup |
| Liam Arch | W | 2024-01-29 | Hillsborough C v Ravenfield A | Div 4 - Athenaeum Cup |
| Kirin Harrington | W | 2024-02-05 | SASCA C v Hillsborough C | Div 4 - Athenaeum Cup |
| Dave Cook | L | 2024-02-19 | Woodseats D v Hillsborough C | Div 4 - Athenaeum Cup |
| Stefan Lewins | L | 2024-03-07 | Chesterfield C v Hillsborough C | Div 4 - Athenaeum Cup |
| Rob Vincent | L | 2024-03-19 | Barnsley C v Hillsborough C | Div 4 - Athenaeum Cup |
| Will Winlow | L | 2024-03-25 | Hillsborough C v Sheffield Nomads D | Div 4 - Athenaeum Cup |
| Eric McKenna | W | 2024-04-15 | Hillsborough C v Darnall & Handsworth D | Div 4 - Athenaeum Cup |
| Alex Thorp | W | 2024-04-29 | Hillsborough C v Woodseats C | Div 4 - Athenaeum Cup |
