| Nigel Baxendale | W | 2023-10-09 | Hillsborough B v Worksop B | Div 2 - Weston Trophy |
| Mark Watson | W | 2023-11-01 | Rotherham A v Hillsborough B | Div 2 - Weston Trophy |
| Ben J Fletcher | W | 2023-11-13 | Hillsborough v Sheffield Deaf | Sam Haystead Memorial Trophy |
| Craig Chatterton | L | 2023-12-11 | Hillsborough B v Darnall & Handsworth B | Div 2 - Weston Trophy |
| Tim Humphries | W | 2024-01-04 | Chesterfield A v Hillsborough A | Div 1 - Davy Trophy |
| Colin Reid | W | 2024-01-08 | Hillsborough v Ecclesall 2 | Sam Haystead Memorial Trophy |
| Vasileios Pasialis | L | 2024-01-15 | Hillsborough B v Sheffield Nomads B | Div 2 - Weston Trophy |
| Jay Ryalls | W | 2024-01-22 | Woodseats A v Hillsborough A | Div 1 - Davy Trophy |
| Richard E Desmedt | L | 2024-02-05 | Hillsborough B v Barnsley A | Div 2 - Weston Trophy |
| Neil Todd | D | 2024-02-15 | Barnsley v Hillsborough | Sam Haystead Memorial Trophy |
| Chris G Willey | D | 2024-02-19 | Hillsborough B v Rotherham A | Div 2 - Weston Trophy |
| Andrew Nettleship | L | 2024-03-04 | Hillsborough A v Darnall & Handsworth A | Div 1 - Davy Trophy |
| Alan S McIntosh | L | 2024-03-13 | Ecclesall B v Hillsborough B | Div 2 - Weston Trophy |
| Phill J Beckett | D | 2024-03-18 | Worksop A v Hillsborough A | Div 1 - Davy Trophy |
