Basingstoke B v Southampton University B
SCL Rob Plate Wed 28th Feb 2024 Verify
| Board | Home | Basingstoke B | Southampton University B | Away | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 (B) | 1651 | G Shaddick, John | 0 - 1 | S Krishnan S K, Jai | 1726 |
| 2 (W) | 1713 | B Cross, Tony | 0 - 1 | S Soenen, Maxime | 1769 |
| 3 (B) | 1443 | S Long, David | 0 - 1 | N Kortman, Milen | 1707 |
| 4 (W) | 1345 | S Dhall, Ojas | 1 - 0 | S Sopocko, Austin | 1548 |
| Adjustment | 3 - -3 | ||||
| Average | 1538 | 4 - 0 | Average | 1688 |
Last update Graham Stuart Mon 11th Mar 2024 10:40. Reported by Graham Stuart Mon 11th Mar 2024 10:36. Verified By
Comments
gstuart
Mon, 11/03/2024 - 10:35
Permalink
Rule Breach
Re: Robertson Plate
We have noticed that the University B team broke league rule 19f in playing Maxime Soenen in the Plate semi-final match against Basingstoke B, as Maxime had already played for the University A team in the Cup competition.
Rule 19g indicates that the penalty is loss of the match, so Basingstoke proceed to the final.
19. ROBERTSON CUP and PLATE
a) Both Cup and Plate competitions are played on a knockout basis.
b) The Cup is open to teams in the top two divisions and any ‘A’ teams in Division 3, while the Plate is open to all other teams.
c) Matches in the Cup are played over 5 boards; matches in the Plate are played over 4 boards.
d) Time control rules are the same as in the league.
e) Any player nominated for a team in the top two divisions of the league or for any ‘A’ team in Division 3 is not eligible to play in the Plate.
f) There is no sharing of players between different teams.
g) The penalty for playing an ineligible player is loss of the match.
SCL Secretary
All games are still rated, but the result will be amended to show that Basingstoke won the match.