Essex v Warwickshire
Under 100 Sat 19th May 2018 Verify
| Board | Home | Essex | Warwickshire | Away | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 (W) | 101A (1413) | G White, Nigel | ½ - ½ | N Donovan, John P | 098C (1440) |
| 2 (B) | 099C () | N Porter, John | 0 - 1 | G Shearsby, Jude | 098A (2229) |
| 3 (W) | 102A () | N Groombridge, Leslie J | ½ - ½ | B Grimes, Adrian | 097C (1405) |
| 4 (B) | 095D () | N Young, Ken A | 0 - 1 | B Stiff, Peter | 092C (1562) |
| 5 (W) | 093C () | N Hazell, Alan | 0 - 1 | B Jones, Malcolm | 092D (1239) |
| 6 (B) | 088C (1385) | B D'Cruz, David | 1 - 0 | N Simpson, Richard | 091C (1331) |
| 7 (W) | 085E (1967) | G Bowden, Madison B | 1 - 0 | G Blair, Jimmy | 089A (1510) |
| 8 (B) | 085C () | N Adams, Trevor | 0 - 1 | N Evans, Tom | 087C () |
| 9 (W) | 083A () | N Sealey, Frank A | ½ - ½ | S Buxton, Richard | 086A (1478) |
| 10 (B) | 074C () | N Cassar, Mario | 1 - 0 | N Leggett, Peter AW | 084A () |
| 11 (W) | 070C () | N Hughes, Peter | 0 - 1 | N Schuler, Marc-Philip | 100* () |
| 12 (B) | 059A (1195) | S Chapman, John R | 1 - 0 | B Green, Des J | 056C (1132) |
| Adjustment | 1 - -1 | ||||
| Penalty | 0 - 1 | ||||
| Average | 87 | 6½ - 4½ | Average | 90 |
Last update Mark Murrell Wed 23rd May 2018 14:54. Reported by Mark Murrell . Verified By Des Green
Comments
dgreen
Sat, 19/05/2018 - 20:32
Permalink
Press / Admin Comment
Essex board 2 was John Porter
Essex board 7 was Madison Bowden
Warwickshire board 11 has an estimated grade of 60 as per the controller.
mmurrell
Sun, 20/05/2018 - 07:26
Permalink
Eligibility ruling awaited
This affects board 11 for Warwickshire. The estimated grade supplied was assigned by the MCCU controller for its earlier qualifying competition and not by the ECF controller as required for the National Stage. Essex new players added
mmurrell
Wed, 23/05/2018 - 14:58
Permalink
Eligibility Ruling
This was made by an independent former CC Controller as both the Controller and Director of Home Chess were recused.
Following precedent, the Warwickshire player on Board 11 was ruled ineligible, with the board score adjusted accordingly and a penalty point deduction applied.
dgreen
Thu, 24/05/2018 - 22:24
Permalink
Eligibility ruling
Warwickshire wish to appeal against the decision that the player on Board 11 was ineligible and are awaiting the procedure to be adopted.
mmurrell
Sat, 26/05/2018 - 18:50
Permalink
Appeal pending
This will be determined by the Appeals Panel convened by the Home Director
mmurrell
Sat, 02/06/2018 - 15:16
Permalink
Appeal decision
The Warwickshire appeal was not successful.